Broken Wings : Why Private Airlines in Ethiopia Are Not Doing as Well as the National Carrier

Ethiopian Airlines, Ethiopia’s flagship national carrier, has been experiencing impressive growth by most measures. The Airline is continually adding planes to its fleet, is expanding the number of international destinations to which it flies, and is generally ranked as one of the most profitable airlines in Africa. Despite the Airline’s promising growth, the same cannot be said of the country’s private airline industry. Ethiopia’s private domestic airlines have had difficulty reaching the consumer market, especially compared to countries like Kenya and Tanzania. EBR’s Berihun Mekonnen explores the reasons why this is the case.

On the 8th of April, 1946, Ethiopian Airlines, Inc. made its maiden flight – from Addis Ababa to Cairo – in a Douglas C-47 Skytrain aircraft. Since then, it has been serving the nation’s international and domestic flight services uninterrupted. Furthermore, the country’s flagship carrier has grown strong and has become one of the most successful and profitable African airliners. It’s also consistently ranked as one of the most globally proficient airlines, owning state-of-the-art aircrafts, continuously adding international routes and destinations, and improving its organization and infrastructure.

But despite the robust growth and prominence of Ethiopia’s national carrier, the private aviation industry of the country lags behind. Compared to other African countries, such as neighboring Kenya and Tanzania, Ethiopia’s private aviation sector is relatively underdeveloped. It has been unable to come out from these predicaments since it began roughly fifteen years ago and its growth has been sluggish. Private airlines have yet to emulate the successes of the national airline, which has become the pride of the nation.

Despite the fact that more than 30 companies have been licensed to operate in the private airline business, only a few are operational. Close to 20 of the licenses given to these companies have been revoked, even after many of them have applied for renewals.

Those that are operational are all involved in charter and taxi services and are usually contracted out to exploration and mining companies, the diplomatic community, international NGOs and, in some instances, for tourists. 

None of them are engaged in providing scheduled domestic flights, which could prove instrumental in improving the country’s transportation system. Many in the sector complain that they are not getting the necessary support from concerned government institutions. They also feel that the sector is highly regulated and restrictions hinder their growth and expansion.

“Restriction and limitations usually hinder creativity and the aspiration to grow,” says Captain Solomon Gizaw, managing director of Abyssinian Flight Services, the first private airliner in the country, when discussing the implications of regulations on the airline industry. He believes that these regulations and restrictions have crippled the growth of the sector. “The sector is over regulated and underserved,” adds Captain Abera Lemi, CEO of National Airways, another private airliner.

Number of seats and age of air-crafts

On October 27, 2014, the first scheduled flight by a private airliner, Trans Nation Airways (TNA), a Midroc-affiliated company, made its maiden flight.  TNA launched its domestic flight from Addis Ababa Bole International Airport to Bahir Dar and Gondar twice a week and to Humera once a week. The flight was realized after the Airline negotiated and agreed with the Ethiopian Civil Aviation Authority (ECAA) about the flight schedules and destinations. 

The most oft-repeated grievance among the private airlines is that they are not able to engage in domestic scheduled flights. This is mainly because of the limitation of the number of seats a private airline aircraft is allowed to have. Until recently, aircrafts were limited to twenty seats, though that number has now been changed to fifty.

The number of seats is the most important factor in determining the fares of transport services, which is pivotal for competition, according to private airline operators.  For them, it is very difficult to compete and be profitable with this number of seats for scheduled commercial flights.  

Many in the sector don’t understand the reasons for placing a limitation on the number of seats. Some suspect that the government is imposing these restrictions in order to protect the government-owned airline from domestic competition.

There are no other countries that limit the number of seats in the private airline business, according to Capitan Abera. The challenge, he claims, is solely placed on Ethiopian private airlines. “It is only when we have a scheduled flight that we can generate sustainable income. We have fixed costs, which may not be covered by charter or taxi services,” Abera explains.

But perhaps the most pressing issue related to regulations on the private airlines, according to industry insiders, is the age limits on aircrafts that are allowed to operate. The ECAA prohibits aircrafts more than 22 years old from being used. Private airline operators say that almost all the aircrafts that meet the required seat number by the Authority are older than the age restriction. 

“There aren’t any new aircrafts in the current market that have this small a number of seats [that would be allowed to operate] in Ethiopia,” says Solomon. “The aircrafts produced recently usually have more than 75 seats. We can’t build what they are requiring of us,” he told EBR in disappointment. Government authorities seem aware of the challenges related to the limitation of the number of seats since they often hold stakeholder discussions. 

Government officials state that these regulations and restrictions are related to the safety and security of passengers, according to Colonel Wosenyeleh Hunegnaw, director general of the ECAA. “The restriction on the age of aircrafts is a safety issue which we will not compromise,” he says. “We have seen data from many African countries and one of the reasons for plane accidents is their age. The issue of safety is for everyone, those that take part in the business as private airliners, the Ethiopian Airlines, and most importantly for all of us as a nation.”

The importance of the air transport sector in Ethiopia cannot be overstated, according to Wosenyeleh. Since Ethiopia is a landlocked country, air transport acts like an unofficial port, helping connect the country to foreign commodities and exchange. Wosenyeleh argues that there is no reason to create obstacles to allow private airlines to operate. The issue, according to the director, is that the sector is highly capital intensive; highly regulated because of safety issues; needs skilled manpower and the competition is stiff.

According to the director, another challenge for private airliners is capacity limitation.  “I doubt they will be able to buy these new aircrafts if the restrictions are lifted,” he told EBR.

When talking about domestic scheduled flights, Wosenyeleh notes that the Ethiopian Airline’s (EAL) service in the domestic air transport is not always a profitable enterprise. There are routes that are profitable and there are routes that lose money, says Wosenyeleh. The Airline compensates one for another and even subsidizes these unprofitable routes with earnings from its international flights. 

The private airlines want to participate in the lucrative routes (markets) but not the others, usually at the expense of the EAL. All things considered, the government doesn’t directly restrict the private operators from the participation of domestic scheduled flights; the number of seats is rather a technical standard and obligation to the private airlines. Policymakers are discussing drafting a new air transport policy that the director hopes will make a significant change.

“Any change, however, won’t be significant and will not make any difference at all in the general aviation,” says Capitan Solomon. “The limitation of the seats wasn’t logical from the beginning,” he adds.

Airport services

Another common complaint from private airlines is the services they receive at airports. Besides mistreatment at airports, they cite the lack of hangars for aircraft maintenance as one of the major challenges. 

Most of the private airline companies take their aircrafts to Kenya or South Africa for maintenance. “Because we don’t have hangars for the maintenance of our aircrafts, we take them to Kenya, which costs substantial money and time, which would otherwise be used for building our capacities,” says Firehiwot Tessema, general manager of Aquarius Aviation. “Though Aquarius is not interested in participating in scheduled flights, since we focus on chartered and taxi services. Capacity limitation is the only challenge of the company.” 

“It has taken 15 years for Abyssinia to get a land on which to build a hangar. During this time we have been taking our aircrafts to Kenya, burning fuel and company costs,” says Solomon. Other airlines express similar frustrations. National Airways takes its aircrafts to South Africa for maintenance purposes because they equip private airlines with hangars there.

All of the private airlines are based in Addis Ababa and use Bole International Airport to provide services. The airports provide services to several airlines, including locally based private companies. According to the Ethiopian Airport Enterprise, some airports have even been able to provide land for airlines to build their own hangars. 

Financial and other support

The country’s investment law bestows the right to invest in the air transport sector in Ethiopia to Ethiopian nationals only. However, the sector hasn’t received the necessary attention from the government, according to some private airline operators. 

Many industry insiders say that it’s difficult to access credit services from financial institutions. Banks, including the publicly-owned Commercial Bank of Ethiopia, don’t have the capacity to meet the financial demands of most private airlines, according to sources.

One of the requirements to work in the air transport sector is to own or lease an aircraft. Though many have registered to get licenses to be engaged in the sector, only a few own aircrafts and have been operational, while most of them don’t own a single aircraft, according to ECAA. The Agency has declined to renew the licenses of 20 private domestic airlines and other aviation businesses on the grounds that they have been using their licenses to do illegitimate business, such as winning contracts and subcontracting them by snatching the jobs of other companies that are operational.

Kaleyesus Bekele is a seasoned journalist at the Reporter newspaper and has been following the development of the sector for more than a decade. He observes that the sector is at a crossroads. Foreign nationals are not allowed to invest in the sector, he says, and since the airline business is capital intensive and it needs technical skills, investors are not interested. Local investors who have joined the sector have limited financial resources and find it difficult to access bank loans, he explains.

Looking forward

A new air transport policy is currently being drafted and policymakers are discussing it at length, according to Wosenyeleh. “The process will involve stakeholders at all levels in order to make it more inclusive and I hope the policy will alleviate challenges and complaints private airline companies raise all the time.” 

“There shouldn’t be any limits,” he argues. “It is because everything is open and free that Virgin Atlantic, a private airliner, is able to transport people to other places,” Abera says.

“The government should consider the private airlines as development partners,” says Kaleyesus. “The first thing that the government should do is to sit down with the private airline owners and listen to their challenges. The ECAA does that at least once a year but the Minister of Transport and the Prime Minister should meet private airlines, owners and discuss the red tape and ways [to move] forward.” EBR

Berihun Mekonnen

EBR Staff Writter

238 comments

  • wedding app

    Fine way of telling, and pleasant post to obtain facts concerning my presentation topic, which i am
    oing to deliver in university. http://femina.rol.ro/forum/discussion/36401/how-to-really-make-your-wedding-a-day-to-remember

    wedding app Sunday, 10 September 2017 04:30 Comment Link
  • RonaldAmold

    treatment for cocaine abuse
    drug and alcohol rehab
    symptoms of taking cocaine
    drug and alcohol rehab
    cocaine substance abuse

    RonaldAmold Saturday, 09 September 2017 15:03 Comment Link
  • DerrickKella

    signs of heroin use in men
    rehab addict
    signs of an ice addict
    rehab addict
    how do people get addicted to heroin

    DerrickKella Friday, 08 September 2017 09:16 Comment Link
  • Phillipp

    tchat voyance gratuite suisse voyance gratuite travail par tchat
    voyance couple gratuit en direct consultation de voyance par mail voyance par
    email gratuite voyance tchat en ligne gratuite voyance 2015
    balance shining voyance fabiola sylvie voyance salon voyance alsace sandra voyance fuveau voyance d'amour gratuite par tchat voyance
    gratuite par tchat sans inscription annuaire voyance symphony 2014 voyance claire arcachon site
    voyance gratuite en ligne horoscope voyance gratuit anthony voyance le
    havre avis voyance gratuite en ligne magie et voyance gratuite line voyance
    rouen voyance gratuit par telephone forum de la voyance 2015 tchat voyance gratuite livre initiation voyance salon voyance rouen 2016
    numero claude voyance skyrock diana voyance tarot jeux de tarot voyance
    gratuite voyance gratuite oui ou non voyance nancy pascal voyance nancy voyance gratuite sans attente sans cb voyance astro center voyance 94100
    voyance gratuite immediate en ligne katleen voyance helena voyance tchat gratuite immediate sans inscription rituel iza voyance avis
    voyance aufeminin fiona voyance avis voyance astro center amely voyance avis chat voyance
    gratuit immediate allo voyance rtl patricia voyance dijon voyance chinoise tarot
    pascal voyance nancy tirage tarot gratuit magie et voyance
    voyance gratuit tarot ligne

    Phillipp Thursday, 07 September 2017 02:36 Comment Link
  • Florene

    plan cul vitry sur seine plan cul en dordogne site de rencontre plan cul plan cul 16 plan cul issy les
    moulineaux forum rencontre plan cul plan cul riom plan cul romilly sur seine plan cul
    cayenne plan cul 100 gratuit plan cul mitry mory
    plan cul 38 rencontre gay plan cul plan cul brive la gaillarde
    plan cul chat plan cul redon forum plan cul gratuit plan cul le pradet plan cul gratuit meilleur site plan cul gratuit plan cul la valette du
    var plan cul cam gratuit plan cul saint leu plan cul valreas plan cul saint gaudens plan cul trets plan cul juvisy sur orge plan cul manche videos plan cul plan cul rive
    de gier plan cul saint chamond plan cul ermont plan cul neuilly
    plaisance plan cul plaisance du touch plan cul dans le 59 plan cul berck plan cul noisy le grand recherche un plan cul plan cul cergy forum site plan cul plan cul seine et marne plan cul
    cormeilles en parisis plan cul valence plan cul clichy sous bois plan cul 45 plan cul
    valbonne plan cul creuse plan cul isere plan cul miramas plan cul gratuits

    Florene Wednesday, 06 September 2017 20:47 Comment Link
  • Richardsom

    neue pille besser viagra
    viagra without a doctor prescription
    how to get viagra from gp
    viagra without doctor
    sildenafil generico 50 mg

    Richardsom Wednesday, 06 September 2017 00:10 Comment Link
  • DennisGer

    want buy viagra usa
    viagra without prescription
    taking half a viagra pill
    viagra without prescription
    can i buy viagra over the counter in malaysia

    DennisGer Tuesday, 05 September 2017 08:29 Comment Link
  • Anthonyloxia

    online viagra risks
    viagra without prescription
    where to get viagra prescription
    viagra without doctor
    sildenafil citrate 100mg australia

    Anthonyloxia Monday, 04 September 2017 11:27 Comment Link
  • Neal

    voyance en ligne gratuite et rapide voyance de qualite et serieuse
    cours de voyance toulouse voyance gratuite magie guide officiel voyance voyance telephone
    gratuite en ligne site gratuit de voyance virtuelle voyance gratuite web magie voyance tarot de belline don de voyance forum cours
    de voyance lyon pascal voyance biarritz katleen voyance salon de la voyance 2015
    nord pas de calais voyance gratuite au telephone voyance a domicile tunisie voyance d amour gratuite en ligne padre voyance ange gardien forum voyance amour gratuite en ligne chat carte de tarot voyance gratuite tchat voyance gratuit sans inscription voyance direct sans
    attente gratuite fiabilite voyance en ligne
    recrutement voyance suisse tchat voyance gratuite en direct voyance avec ma date de
    naissance voyance horoscope balance voyance gratuite oui ou non avis sur la voyance
    nostradamus marina voyance la ferte bernard
    voyance megane tarot et divination numero de voyance
    par sms gratuit meilleur site voyance en ligne skyrock voyance numero de telephone voyance gratuite par telephone
    voyance gratuite avenir voyance gratuite carte prenom voyance gratuite sans donner email astro voyance tarot gratuit voyance du jour gemeaux chat voyance gratuit sans
    inscription claire thomas voyance temoignage voyance forum magie voyance
    tarot de marseille celia voyance avis jeu de voyance d'amour voyance benevole par telephone voyance sans carte
    bleue voyance qualite avis yamma comment creer
    un site de voyance payant

    Neal Sunday, 03 September 2017 22:42 Comment Link
  • Edwardkab

    pharmacy price for viagra
    viagra without a doctor prescription
    cheapest generic viagra and cialis
    viagra without doctor
    where to buy viagra online in uk

    Edwardkab Saturday, 02 September 2017 09:14 Comment Link

Leave a comment

Make sure you enter the (*) required information where indicated.Basic HTML code is allowed.

Latest News

Ethiopia to Host the 4th International Coffee Conference

Ethiopia to Host the 4th International Coffee Conference

Ethiopia is set to host the 4th International Coffee Conference from March 6 – 8, 2016 in Addis Ababa at the United Nations Conference Center. Previous conferences were held  in England in 2001, Brazil in 2005 and Guatemala in 2010. Read more

Most Popular

  • 1
  • 2
Prev Next

The White-Box of Ethiopian Agriculture

The agricultural sector remains our Achilles heel, nonetheless, we remain convinced that agricultural-based development remains the only source of hope ...

Read more

For Whoever Has, to Him Shall be Given …

As the Ethiopian government seeks to transform the economy into one that’s rooted in manufacturing, the simplicity for local investors to access finance...

Read more

Commentary

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
Prev Next

Shooting in the Dark: The Anomalies of Headhunting

The war for ‘heads’ – also known as talent – has been raging for many years and the manner headhunters ‘poach’ people is getting tougher ...

Read more

Understanding Chinese Investment in Ethiopia A Critical Evaluation of the World Bank’s “Chinese FDI in Ethiopia” Survey

The World Bank country office in Ethiopia, apparently in response to the request by the government of Ethiopia, has conducted a survey of...

Read more

Mitigating Growing Income Inequality: What Needs to Be Done

Rising income and wealth inequality in many countries around the world has been a long-term trend for three decades or more. But the atte...

Read more

View Point

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
Prev Next

Delivering Life Insurance: The Untapped Market in Ethiopia

Modern insurance transaction in Ethiopia was started by an Egyptian Bank in 1905. According to Ethiopian Chamber of Commerce there were 19, 33 and 40 insuran...

Read more

Headache When a Key Personnel leaves a Company in the Financial Sector

The financial sector in Ethiopia has undergone considerable changes in recent decades. The dramatic rise of new market players into the sector has vividly al...

Read more

Women and the World Economy

In many countries, public debate about gender equality focuses mainly on women’s access to top positions and high-powered career opportunities. But the “glas...

Read more