Understanding Chinese Investment in Ethiopia A Critical Evaluation of the World Bank’s “Chinese FDI in Ethiopia” Survey

The World Bank country office in Ethiopia, apparently in response to the request by the government of Ethiopia, has conducted a survey of Chinese FDI (Foreign Direct Investment) in Ethiopia in November 2012. This is a commendable job on the part of the World Bank as Chinese related investments are increasingly becoming important not only in Ethiopia but also across the continent.

Major findings of the study include the growth of FDI from China to Ethiopia from zero in 2004 to about USD 60 million in 2010 and how Chinese FDI in Ethiopia is motivated by the desire to take advantage of the current state of the economy, which the Bank says is growing at a rate of 10Pct in the past few years. According to the study, this increasing Chinese FDI is also motivated by the incentive provided by the governments of China and Ethiopia, political stability in the country and the idea of using Ethiopia as a strategic launching pad for Chinese expansion in the rest of Africa.

The study also points how the Chinese FDI in Ethiopia is found to be constrained by inefficient Ethiopian bureaucracy, foreign exchange risk, lack of finance and skilled labor in the economy, companies spending valuable company time dealing with government officials and their regulation, where the government is taking over 30Pct of senior Chinese management time.

Thus, on the basis of the above findings the World Bank’s study not only offers policy recommendation for improvement but also provided us with quantitative data which are very difficult to get.

Be that as it may, I have two major problems with this study that is carried out to understand ‘Chinese investment engagement’ in Ethiopia. It is legitimate to infer that the World Bank’s motivation for this study is to understand the role of Chinese investment on technological transfer, industrialization and development of Ethiopia through investment, as that is explicitly noted in the document. If this is the case, first, presenting a survey of FDI in Ethiopia without contextualizing it in the total FDI flows and stock to/in the country, or in comparative terms, say Ethiopia’s share vis-à-vis the same share among African countries, gives the impression that this Chinese FDI is important in Ethiopia.

In reality, however, the Chinese FDI in Ethiopia is not actually that important and negligible at best. For instance, in the whole of Africa, the main source countries for FDI flows are still the developed (OECD) countries which command over 72Pct of the flows between 2000 and 2008 and 90Pct of the stock in 2008. Among them, France, UK, Germany and the US are very important.

Thus, FDI flows from emerging economies to Africa, although growing very fast, is not that big in terms of relative magnitude. Even the much talked about Chinese FDI in Africa share -FDI stock of USD 17.7 billion in 2010 in the whole of Africa- is also rather small being about 3.2Pct of Africa’s total stock of FDI in 2010.

In Ethiopia the World Bank survey under discussion offers a figure of USD 58 million in 2010 and USD 74.3 million in 2009 as Chinese FDI in the country. This is consistent with that of Chinese Ministry of Commerce. However, if the World Bank didn’t fail to go a bit further, it would have discovered figures that were much less in the previous periods; just USD9.7 million in 2008 and USD 13.2 million in 2007, USD 23.9 million in 2006 and USD 4 million in 2005. Thus, the average annual figure since 2005 is just USD 18.3 million. In Ethiopia, the Chinese FDI as a percentage of the total FDI flow to the country since 2005 is just 6.9Pct. So the question is: does the FDI survey under analysis deserves all the resource and attention of the World Bank, if the objective is to understand the Chinese investment engagement in Ethiopia? I do not think so. This will take me to my next critique of the study.

The second major problem with this World Bank survey relates to the implicit undertone that it gives about Chinese investment in Ethiopia. The study implicitly suggests that ‘this is the Chinese investment engagement situation in Ethiopia’. If one wants to understand Chinese investment engagement in Ethiopia, I believe one has to study what I call Chinese Quasi-FDI in Ethiopia, not the Chinese FDI in Ethiopia using the standard or ‘traditional’ definition of FDI as the World Bank did.

What I would like to call Quasi-FDI could be understood as follows. In addition to direct investment, Chinese firms are also active in major investment activities that are being carried by the governments of Africa such as Ethiopia, especially in infrastructure. We may not take such investment as FDI as such, since it is an investment that is basically carried by the government of Ethiopia or any African country in question with Chinese financing. However, given that most of these projects wouldn’t have been realized without Chinese or other emerging South economies’ financing and engagement, we may refer to them as Quasi-FDI. As can be inferred from the Ethiopian case, such investments are generally more important in showing the Chinese investment engagement in Ethiopia, and also in the continent at large, than the level of FDI using the official or standard definition noted. In Ethiopian case for instance, the Chinese official FDI averages to just about USD18 million per annum, between 2005 and 2010, as we noted above. In this sense, the official figures of FDI greatly understated the actual investment engagement of Chinese entities in Ethiopia, where the Chinese Quasi-FDI in Ethiopia is over USD6.5 billion in major infrastructure projects that are underway since 2009 alone. This makes the Chinese FDI studied by the World Bank 0.00000028Pct of the Chinese Quasi-FDI in Ethiopia - Yes you read it right! 6 zeros before 28!.

In Ethiopia, the Chinese are involved nearly in all power generation projects, except some handled by an Italian firm named Salini, irrespective of the financier of the project. By 2009 the value of such projects is estimated at about USD 1.7 billion. This is in addition to power transmission projects and the government’s universal access program which together amounts to about USD 373 million. This figure must have gone even larger by 2013.

In the transport/road sector, Chinese companies have totally dominated the Ethiopian scene. In general, there were about ten Chinese firms engaged in the construction of roads throughout the country in 2009/10. These firms were engaged in about 60Pct of the road works being carried out in the country. The over 2,000km national and about 30km Addis Ababa railway construction is totally dominated by Chinese firms that brought with them financing. By 2009 the total value of Chinese projects in the road sector has reached over USD0.6 billion. The railway deal with China is estimated at USD3 billion, USD2.1 billion for the national project and about USD0.5 billion for light city rails in Addis Ababa. The same goes in delivering telecommunication technologies.

Invariably Chinese firms that won big contracts are seen remaining in Ethiopia by opening offices and local subsidiaries of their company in the course of their first project in Ethiopia. The Bank survey, hopefully have included these in the data (not reported). In fact the investment data in the last five years shows a growing number of Chinese-Ethiopian joint ventures too, although I was hoping the Bank survey would say a lot about this as it is the main channel for technology transfer and local ownership. Unfortunately we can’t see details of this phenomenon in the survey, except its share which is about 15Pct. It is curious to note in passing, however, that the more the Chinese firms work with the Ethiopian private sector the more they found dealing with government problematic, as can be read from the survey graphs.

Before concluding this article, however, I hasten to add that surveying about FDI using the standard definition as done by the World Bank in the report under analysis is a legitimate research and scientific practice. So, there is nothing wrong with it as long as you have the luxury of spending resources and time on comparatively less important issue with regard to Chinese investment engagement in Ethiopia. In the context of the latter view, definitely the priority given by the bank to the pure FDI study if not outright wrong, is not impressive. More importantly, it may also give a wrong signal about the issue under analysis - Chinese investment engagement in Ethiopia.

Abebe Asamere

Abebe Asamere holds an LLB in Law and BA in Political Science and International Relations from AAU. He was a member of the executive committee and pro bono legal advisor of the Ethiopian Consumers Protection Association for six years. Later on he became president of the Association for about a year. Since 2000, he has been working as consultant and attorney at Law. He was also teaching business law at the School of Commerce at AAU on part time basis for several years. Comments can be sent to abebe.a@ethiopianbusinessreview.com or aasamere@yahoo.com

102 comments

  • GrahamGlymn

    Sildenafil Uses And Side Effects hzjjm 167770 774693 sdmrz Sildenafil Revatio Generic xogmg 375698 249392 vnggv Cialis Tadalafil Canada naupg 826357 547786 fjjhd Price Of Viagra At vrwye 439675 996150 hbvnk Compare Price Generic Cialis ndxfy 617897 833135 yrrcu Cialis From Canada Without A Prescription gqinn 399405 422818 gcmqc Average Retail Price Of Cialis hpzrv 493861 557136 napvb Online Cialis Paypal Canada kdfjw 834593 778471 sycqt Viagra 100 Vs Cialis 20 azorv 376273 7972 crbnb Cialis Canada Shop apjpo 273269 87275 wsnbs How To Buy Viagra From Canada hqkju 398161 450001 pdvoz Is A Perscriptio Required For Viagra In Canada wiumb 678092 484260 nvppu Comprar Cialis En Canada qojhz 881637 254376 njcdb Sildenafil Over The Counter USA ktvhx 537999 968527 evyec Canadian Drug Store Viagra qxkac 698502 145415 jdmkw Is Buying Canadian Viagra A Good Idea jkyft 311200 178758 qobyg Canadian Online Pharmacy Generic Viagra dyeum 944392 592860 vxbnz Price For Viagra In Canada uilre 349266 714810 llmhz Canada Cialis 60 Mg qeubn 792095 53017 tqcvq Is Cialis Generic Available In Canada leeze 433042 534101 bbdox Generic Viagra Online Checks Accepted India ytdxt 285114 239347 aphtp Best Generic Drugs Cialis swvps 231798 854782 qfbyt Viagra 100 Mg Tablet Price pzypp 501555 947744 sjfju Generic Viagra Fake plrvz 419869 111968 rosat Raymeds Generic Viagra jxeyh 736210 960554 ztzmw Canadian Pharmacy For For Generic Viagra From India fkwqk 650976 452142 kxxfa

    GrahamGlymn Tuesday, 25 April 2017 12:02 Comment Link
  • GrahamGlymn

    jsmeo 969158 352899 miiag VIAGRA WITHOUT A DOCTOR PRESCRIPTION fwggs 249790 417684 hlsaf VIAGRA WITHOUT A DOCTOR PRESCRIPTION FROM CANADA flvtm 174538 860168 dsvdq CIALIS LOWEST PRICE obbaf 714233 518154 katps SILDENAFIL 20 MG TABLET opwsi 460501 149814 ectyi SILDENAFIL CITRATE 100MG oylut 939540 315095 bbtaz SILDENAFIL 20 MG mggut 59694 926076 ubcfo

    GrahamGlymn Saturday, 22 April 2017 19:17 Comment Link
  • GrahamGlymn

    wocax 569458 346515 zafur VIAGRA WITHOUT A DOCTOR PRESCRIPTION gubhl 746157 809663 kyayr VIAGRA WITHOUT A DOCTOR PRESCRIPTION FROM CANADA ourlh 381124 69907 tysyd CIALIS LOWEST PRICE otfde 523210 745765 fylnn SILDENAFIL 20 MG TABLET lbvxh 997575 403713 bwvyk SILDENAFIL CITRATE 100MG uaqmv 285877 271622 vedbo SILDENAFIL 20 MG zznab 852750 183643 latdp

    GrahamGlymn Saturday, 22 April 2017 18:54 Comment Link
  • GrahamGlymn

    ysolb 705581 526183 irfor VIAGRA WITHOUT A DOCTOR PRESCRIPTION ygcpy 79814 371546 artii VIAGRA WITHOUT A DOCTOR PRESCRIPTION FROM CANADA eskih 507149 96512 nhtgc CIALIS LOWEST PRICE hjrck 986064 328473 ksglh SILDENAFIL 20 MG TABLET vdejp 401558 553223 pwhar SILDENAFIL CITRATE 100MG pruqa 183421 468778 qkmko SILDENAFIL 20 MG ylajh 531876 176112 tplwk

    GrahamGlymn Friday, 21 April 2017 23:31 Comment Link
  • Davidjet

    lptup 262667 928664 vgced VIAGRA WITHOUT A DOCTOR PRESCRIPTION wckwg 461681 205782 ckool VIAGRA WITHOUT A DOCTOR PRESCRIPTION FROM CANADA zjlvb 280283 402999 mmxqj CIALIS LOWEST PRICE vaswq 73293 981183 yewyr SILDENAFIL 20 MG TABLET ddjch 480629 893098 hrjjv SILDENAFIL CITRATE 100MG epduh 510623 312478 grgeg SILDENAFIL 20 MG horpw 319618 844533 hflwx

    Davidjet Friday, 21 April 2017 23:23 Comment Link
  • GrahamGlymn

    fpvbc 433142 940871 mscmr VIAGRA WITHOUT A DOCTOR PRESCRIPTION lwfjk 402560 269373 xomkl VIAGRA WITHOUT A DOCTOR PRESCRIPTION FROM CANADA tbnjb 229402 558591 tclus CIALIS LOWEST PRICE vozhi 6391 261649 nxcdd SILDENAFIL 20 MG TABLET vwxly 752191 746522 qpaoz SILDENAFIL CITRATE 100MG smdwa 933680 719913 ugpav SILDENAFIL 20 MG nferv 551706 468534 axdjz

    GrahamGlymn Friday, 21 April 2017 11:57 Comment Link
  • GrahamGlymn

    jruqx 446375 52094 nhmgb VIAGRA WITHOUT A DOCTOR PRESCRIPTION ziguu 828443 474108 ahptw VIAGRA WITHOUT A DOCTOR PRESCRIPTION FROM CANADA govva 595629 689395 wsouv CIALIS LOWEST PRICE vuwyp 397811 339206 lyahd SILDENAFIL 20 MG TABLET bfblx 904742 636798 kjihx SILDENAFIL CITRATE 100MG kehku 561720 958323 qncnr SILDENAFIL 20 MG wvfkj 80619 110461 pskxk

    GrahamGlymn Friday, 21 April 2017 09:03 Comment Link
  • GrahamGlymn

    xuydz 332460 400157 ylcgq VIAGRA 100mg Tablets Retail Price fv 361131 843764 ogepv VIAGRA 100mg Tablets Retail Price 878650 ekghn Best Price VIAGRA 634246 mfpif Best Price VIAGRA dovsb 31979 828938 owwfs http://viagra100mgtabletsretailpriusa.com/ enmg439007 568176 162280 587238 799861 Viagra Canadian nhscb 843844 943633 tkqku

    GrahamGlymn Friday, 14 April 2017 19:49 Comment Link
  • GrahamGlymn

    kgfjk 86537 153297 hinlj VIAGRA 100mg Tablets Retail Price kr 522053 261818 nhmni VIAGRA 100mg Tablets Retail Price 702501 kclog Generic VIAGRA Online Pharmacy 14712 bbjqx Generic VIAGRA Online Pharmacy vezuc 98652 107067 xkxlr http://genericviagraonlinepharmacyusa.com/ yoqz368025 917988 249157 531740 928199 Canadian Pharcharmy Online No Script Needed elrcb 901041 671611 xerwu

    GrahamGlymn Friday, 14 April 2017 19:40 Comment Link
  • BillySen

    lhpbg 468130 662880 dfsnj Generic VIAGRA Online Pharmacy jn 452765 617404 dlphe VIAGRA Online Canada Pharmacy 391695 yyjes Generic VIAGRA Online Pharmacy 833058 agxvl VIAGRA 100mg Tablets Retail Price pkqia 490922 469268 umisg http://genericviagraonlinepharmacyusa.com/ xnht836789 413864 288627 528555 904709 Buying Generic Drugs Online Canada vzoqy 277377 981550 wfnhs

    BillySen Thursday, 13 April 2017 23:57 Comment Link

Leave a comment

Make sure you enter the (*) required information where indicated.Basic HTML code is allowed.

Latest News

Ethiopia to Host the 4th International Coffee Conference

Ethiopia to Host the 4th International Coffee Conference

Ethiopia is set to host the 4th International Coffee Conference from March 6 – 8, 2016 in Addis Ababa at the United Nations Conference Center. Previous conferences were held  in England in 2001, Brazil in 2005 and Guatemala in 2010. Read more

Most Popular

  • 1
  • 2
Prev Next

The White-Box of Ethiopian Agriculture

The agricultural sector remains our Achilles heel, nonetheless, we remain convinced that agricultural-based development remains the only source of hope ...

Read more

For Whoever Has, to Him Shall be Given …

As the Ethiopian government seeks to transform the economy into one that’s rooted in manufacturing, the simplicity for local investors to access finance...

Read more

Commentary

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
Prev Next

Shooting in the Dark: The Anomalies of Headhunting

The war for ‘heads’ – also known as talent – has been raging for many years and the manner headhunters ‘poach’ people is getting tougher ...

Read more

Understanding Chinese Investment in Ethiopia A Critical Evaluation of the World Bank’s “Chinese FDI in Ethiopia” Survey

The World Bank country office in Ethiopia, apparently in response to the request by the government of Ethiopia, has conducted a survey of...

Read more

Mitigating Growing Income Inequality: What Needs to Be Done

Rising income and wealth inequality in many countries around the world has been a long-term trend for three decades or more. But the atte...

Read more

View Point

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
Prev Next

Delivering Life Insurance: The Untapped Market in Ethiopia

Modern insurance transaction in Ethiopia was started by an Egyptian Bank in 1905. According to Ethiopian Chamber of Commerce there were 19, 33 and 40 insuran...

Read more

Headache When a Key Personnel leaves a Company in the Financial Sector

The financial sector in Ethiopia has undergone considerable changes in recent decades. The dramatic rise of new market players into the sector has vividly al...

Read more

Women and the World Economy

In many countries, public debate about gender equality focuses mainly on women’s access to top positions and high-powered career opportunities. But the “glas...

Read more