Understanding Chinese Investment in Ethiopia A Critical Evaluation of the World Bank’s “Chinese FDI in Ethiopia” Survey

The World Bank country office in Ethiopia, apparently in response to the request by the government of Ethiopia, has conducted a survey of Chinese FDI (Foreign Direct Investment) in Ethiopia in November 2012. This is a commendable job on the part of the World Bank as Chinese related investments are increasingly becoming important not only in Ethiopia but also across the continent.

Major findings of the study include the growth of FDI from China to Ethiopia from zero in 2004 to about USD 60 million in 2010 and how Chinese FDI in Ethiopia is motivated by the desire to take advantage of the current state of the economy, which the Bank says is growing at a rate of 10Pct in the past few years. According to the study, this increasing Chinese FDI is also motivated by the incentive provided by the governments of China and Ethiopia, political stability in the country and the idea of using Ethiopia as a strategic launching pad for Chinese expansion in the rest of Africa.

The study also points how the Chinese FDI in Ethiopia is found to be constrained by inefficient Ethiopian bureaucracy, foreign exchange risk, lack of finance and skilled labor in the economy, companies spending valuable company time dealing with government officials and their regulation, where the government is taking over 30Pct of senior Chinese management time.

Thus, on the basis of the above findings the World Bank’s study not only offers policy recommendation for improvement but also provided us with quantitative data which are very difficult to get.

Be that as it may, I have two major problems with this study that is carried out to understand ‘Chinese investment engagement’ in Ethiopia. It is legitimate to infer that the World Bank’s motivation for this study is to understand the role of Chinese investment on technological transfer, industrialization and development of Ethiopia through investment, as that is explicitly noted in the document. If this is the case, first, presenting a survey of FDI in Ethiopia without contextualizing it in the total FDI flows and stock to/in the country, or in comparative terms, say Ethiopia’s share vis-à-vis the same share among African countries, gives the impression that this Chinese FDI is important in Ethiopia.

In reality, however, the Chinese FDI in Ethiopia is not actually that important and negligible at best. For instance, in the whole of Africa, the main source countries for FDI flows are still the developed (OECD) countries which command over 72Pct of the flows between 2000 and 2008 and 90Pct of the stock in 2008. Among them, France, UK, Germany and the US are very important.

Thus, FDI flows from emerging economies to Africa, although growing very fast, is not that big in terms of relative magnitude. Even the much talked about Chinese FDI in Africa share -FDI stock of USD 17.7 billion in 2010 in the whole of Africa- is also rather small being about 3.2Pct of Africa’s total stock of FDI in 2010.

In Ethiopia the World Bank survey under discussion offers a figure of USD 58 million in 2010 and USD 74.3 million in 2009 as Chinese FDI in the country. This is consistent with that of Chinese Ministry of Commerce. However, if the World Bank didn’t fail to go a bit further, it would have discovered figures that were much less in the previous periods; just USD9.7 million in 2008 and USD 13.2 million in 2007, USD 23.9 million in 2006 and USD 4 million in 2005. Thus, the average annual figure since 2005 is just USD 18.3 million. In Ethiopia, the Chinese FDI as a percentage of the total FDI flow to the country since 2005 is just 6.9Pct. So the question is: does the FDI survey under analysis deserves all the resource and attention of the World Bank, if the objective is to understand the Chinese investment engagement in Ethiopia? I do not think so. This will take me to my next critique of the study.

The second major problem with this World Bank survey relates to the implicit undertone that it gives about Chinese investment in Ethiopia. The study implicitly suggests that ‘this is the Chinese investment engagement situation in Ethiopia’. If one wants to understand Chinese investment engagement in Ethiopia, I believe one has to study what I call Chinese Quasi-FDI in Ethiopia, not the Chinese FDI in Ethiopia using the standard or ‘traditional’ definition of FDI as the World Bank did.

What I would like to call Quasi-FDI could be understood as follows. In addition to direct investment, Chinese firms are also active in major investment activities that are being carried by the governments of Africa such as Ethiopia, especially in infrastructure. We may not take such investment as FDI as such, since it is an investment that is basically carried by the government of Ethiopia or any African country in question with Chinese financing. However, given that most of these projects wouldn’t have been realized without Chinese or other emerging South economies’ financing and engagement, we may refer to them as Quasi-FDI. As can be inferred from the Ethiopian case, such investments are generally more important in showing the Chinese investment engagement in Ethiopia, and also in the continent at large, than the level of FDI using the official or standard definition noted. In Ethiopian case for instance, the Chinese official FDI averages to just about USD18 million per annum, between 2005 and 2010, as we noted above. In this sense, the official figures of FDI greatly understated the actual investment engagement of Chinese entities in Ethiopia, where the Chinese Quasi-FDI in Ethiopia is over USD6.5 billion in major infrastructure projects that are underway since 2009 alone. This makes the Chinese FDI studied by the World Bank 0.00000028Pct of the Chinese Quasi-FDI in Ethiopia - Yes you read it right! 6 zeros before 28!.

In Ethiopia, the Chinese are involved nearly in all power generation projects, except some handled by an Italian firm named Salini, irrespective of the financier of the project. By 2009 the value of such projects is estimated at about USD 1.7 billion. This is in addition to power transmission projects and the government’s universal access program which together amounts to about USD 373 million. This figure must have gone even larger by 2013.

In the transport/road sector, Chinese companies have totally dominated the Ethiopian scene. In general, there were about ten Chinese firms engaged in the construction of roads throughout the country in 2009/10. These firms were engaged in about 60Pct of the road works being carried out in the country. The over 2,000km national and about 30km Addis Ababa railway construction is totally dominated by Chinese firms that brought with them financing. By 2009 the total value of Chinese projects in the road sector has reached over USD0.6 billion. The railway deal with China is estimated at USD3 billion, USD2.1 billion for the national project and about USD0.5 billion for light city rails in Addis Ababa. The same goes in delivering telecommunication technologies.

Invariably Chinese firms that won big contracts are seen remaining in Ethiopia by opening offices and local subsidiaries of their company in the course of their first project in Ethiopia. The Bank survey, hopefully have included these in the data (not reported). In fact the investment data in the last five years shows a growing number of Chinese-Ethiopian joint ventures too, although I was hoping the Bank survey would say a lot about this as it is the main channel for technology transfer and local ownership. Unfortunately we can’t see details of this phenomenon in the survey, except its share which is about 15Pct. It is curious to note in passing, however, that the more the Chinese firms work with the Ethiopian private sector the more they found dealing with government problematic, as can be read from the survey graphs.

Before concluding this article, however, I hasten to add that surveying about FDI using the standard definition as done by the World Bank in the report under analysis is a legitimate research and scientific practice. So, there is nothing wrong with it as long as you have the luxury of spending resources and time on comparatively less important issue with regard to Chinese investment engagement in Ethiopia. In the context of the latter view, definitely the priority given by the bank to the pure FDI study if not outright wrong, is not impressive. More importantly, it may also give a wrong signal about the issue under analysis - Chinese investment engagement in Ethiopia.

Abebe Asamere

Abebe Asamere holds an LLB in Law and BA in Political Science and International Relations from AAU. He was a member of the executive committee and pro bono legal advisor of the Ethiopian Consumers Protection Association for six years. Later on he became president of the Association for about a year. Since 2000, he has been working as consultant and attorney at Law. He was also teaching business law at the School of Commerce at AAU on part time basis for several years. Comments can be sent to abebe.a@ethiopianbusinessreview.com or aasamere@yahoo.com

102 comments

  • Varnoexisp

    payday loans sarasota florida

    fast payday loans

    cash advance

    Irving Tex. cash advance

    Varnoexisp Friday, 16 June 2017 18:50 Comment Link
  • Andrewexisp

    personal loan oklahoma city

    http://nofaxpaydaynvz.com/ - no faxing payday advance

    no fax payday loan

    income tax on unsecured loans

    Andrewexisp Saturday, 10 June 2017 18:08 Comment Link
  • Milford

    That is really interesting, You are an overly skilled blogger.
    I have joined your rss feed and sit up for looking for extra of your
    excellent post. Also, I have shared your website in my social networks

    Milford Thursday, 01 June 2017 17:54 Comment Link
  • Melvin

    Great article! This is the kind of info that are supposed to be shared
    around the internet. Disgrace on the search engines for no longer positioning this publish upper!
    Come on over and talk over with my web site . Thank
    you =)

    Melvin Thursday, 01 June 2017 13:08 Comment Link
  • Major

    I am really grateful to the owner of this web page who
    has shared this fantastic article at here.

    Major Thursday, 01 June 2017 11:51 Comment Link
  • viagra without a doctors prescription

    http://vigrawithoutadoctorprescription.com viagra without a doctor prescription

    viagra without a doctors prescription Thursday, 01 June 2017 06:35 Comment Link
  • GrahamGlymn

    Generic Sildenafil 100mg mdayz 602570 575222 awjhl Otc Sildenafil hncqb 680651 624252 xxbnx Cialis 40 Mg In Canada Pharmacy zrrry 145373 94629 djwuo Price On Viagra wkjmr 982153 274278 owmhi Viagra Cialis Price Comparison tuwub 122690 562990 ocvzq Can I Buy Viagra Over The Counter In Canada cmhnb 298045 680740 lmjaf Cialis Retail Price In Ct juwpt 978814 99817 xvzwn Where To Buy Cialis Online In Canada rzgzp 555060 824435 qqxld 50 Mg Viagra Vs 20 Mg Cialis kuzfh 39982 380078 rgsnv Canadian Company That Sells Viagra bsiqy 664386 512983 gydyr List Of Canadian Pharmacies On Line Selss Cialis cwvga 626067 761050 mrzdg Where Can I Buy Viagra Canada andzd 847107 193569 cenkk Best Viagra Knock Off Canadian Pill ksvgm 552985 940816 hplzz Sildenafil 100mg xfzmi 185850 37358 cumhe Best Price For Genuine Canadian Cialis ccuzu 86712 827947 cowva Viagra Canada Overnight Shipping tqisu 634947 332091 tvupl Best Online Pharmacy For Viagra Review 2015 xhdbw 242828 466999 wrvwo Cialis Canadian Pharmacy Price qxuff 589570 560188 rlqqd Is Viagra Available Over The Counter In Canada udjdw 431976 396628 scsnv Canadian Pharmacy 10mg Cialis kmcdg 724657 591428 rspsb Generic Viagra Online Canadian No Prescription strkc 143963 279093 lexmt Buy Generic Cialis Online With Paypal vgycv 729485 994473 lemks Viagra 100 Mg Best Price tblwf 454082 93978 nmbzq Best Generic Viagra Prices ezrop 845963 882659 nxrwj Buy Generic Viagra Without Prescription xjefa 936982 197777 zsmoj Viagra Cheapest Prices Canada giwji 330659 769009 jbmsh

    GrahamGlymn Sunday, 30 April 2017 06:44 Comment Link
  • Russelljerse

    200 Mg Sildenafil Citrate ptpal 312976 334931 ylozk Buy Sildenafil 100mg Online gjkkb 72824 497325 lcxug Cialis For Sale Online In Canada ijxtb 510293 997435 yzjkt Female Viagra Stock Price rxrhy 950535 499373 jsumx Cialis 5mg Vs 20mg Price afiae 690827 48601 vcori Viagra Sales In Canada jakrf 740455 816311 rvrob Cialis Black Price ndyix 151270 564036 fmgce Canada Online Pharmacy Viagra hhfkz 646343 46258 ntkrj Cialis Vs Levitra Vs Viagra Which One Is Better uwoih 799899 785888 lcobz Generic Cialis Canada fhhfo 320196 903747 eabrv 100mg Viagra From Canada dzgxw 652712 343802 hwvay Online Canadian Pharmacy Viagra uchkt 520794 307415 prbzg Viagra 25mg Online Canada isvxg 536318 712715 xetpc Sildenafil Citrate 100mg From India icgmx 932187 532944 kxykk Buy Generic Viagra Canadian Pharmacies vyefn 584846 218880 nbmnn Canada Pharmacy Viagra gnysj 53108 861320 ejxic Buy Viagra Online Lloyds Pharmacy ewsbf 802725 328379 hiwbr Buy Viagra Online In Canada blqub 819315 907347 cgdze Word Press Hack Redirects To Canadian Viagra 2016 pliky 610693 179911 yvwdd Achat Viagra En Ligne Canada wiclx 551518 466670 wvxiz Legitimate Generic Viagra Online bfneq 711346 418378 mrsul Generic Cialis About Having A Prescription cgduj 994368 583814 gwpgj Real Viagra Price owkoh 115401 910198 oiaij Generic Viagra Safe xtgfq 189588 431470 ecdjo Is Buying Generic Viagra Online Safe gtdfs 573189 937889 yigqu How To Get Canadian Cialis vtleh 770979 814841 inaiy Sildenafil No Prescription rfpxd 270146 542724 ebxlt Buy Sildenafil Without Prescription mncvc 543505 486991 ueivx Can I Get Cialis From Canada znjvk 282745 872794 yxsvg 50 Mg Viagra Price cyalu 975237 294101 iavhj Price Of Cialis 20mg evafp 264983 261898 ooxpc Pharmacy In Windsor Canada For Viagra vhoni 52220 275993 wvjaw Price For 5mg Cialis vdlsf 957575 375118 uqglv Cheap Generic Viagra Canadian Pharmacy ohpcs 884833 539693 gawqo Viagra Vs Cialis Vs Levitra Dosage ldvgy 695017 671901 sqvoo Canadian Phramacy Cialis htmny 72323 814576 lheha Is It Legal To Order Cialis From Canada stfay 942160 719752 lhvzn How Safe Is It To Buy Viagra From Canada gibhf 192623 399443 zdlob Viagra Canada Best Price dsten 334265 103513 hvfgk Cialis Vs Sildenafil rdmad 449512 537039 kbteq Cialis From Legitimate Canada Pharmacies efkfp 535377 879346 viznc Where To Buy Viagra Online From Canada dnupd 541482 412667 pjjay Most Reliable Online Pharmacy Viagra xlosp 781592 281285 izaqw Viagra From Canada Without A Prescription abkhy 778542 783130 cchkw Canada Cialis No Prescription xcrxy 50981 764236 zuzli Canada Viagra Top Pharmacy Reviews vjrzf 427311 12739 vlaas Best Online Pharmicies For Generic Viagra zjrdn 713091 22941 vrxjt Cheapest Place To Buy Generic Cialis mydfz 773528 837042 gljdl Price On Viagra At Food Lion chyit 70480 424288 qkzfh Cheap Generic Viagra Online Review cplta 517101 804869 uivzu Teva Generic Viagra ufnqv 725286 892884 ikcgk Getting Viagra From Canada Is It Safe tcjcn 420468 877548 sifpl Manforce Sildenafil Citrate Tablets powhx 997755 759532 kvfkm Generic Sildenafil dpovx 678894 403441 qhyug Canadian Cialis Prescription spqlt 3526 981674 vuvwu Price Comparison Viagra Cialis zvuda 833875 448644 vcowu Cialis Everyday Price ypzfz 274826 536455 rkqob Viagra Generic Canada Retail Outlets cshkj 270544 563299 stisj Cialis Lilly Price lcyjb 299949 233358 rxkde Viagra Patent Canada iqpwh 989379 310075 pcmfv Review Viagra Vs Cialis txogh 868112 756839 bvqmb Canadian Pharmacy For Cialis ubocc 484136 589355 buuau Fill A Viagra Prescription In Canada crfru 955399 992534 pqnwo Viagra Rx Canada oksyk 754186 777116 eldjt Reliable Cialis Supplier In Canada cajpq 884588 676010 eutkv Sildenafil Teva 50mg nrycy 792950 258892 jqzfy Is Viagra From Canada Safe ollrd 949654 693003 evmav Canadian Prices For Viagra pobnv 887259 908989 zbnvg Safe Online Pharmacy To Get Viagra slacy 427187 17377 lbevv Canadian Viagra Comprare lefyx 797831 740934 ablke Cost Of Viagra Canada exkfw 214355 859910 cdopj Anybody Visit Canada For Cialis axoix 931103 155282 qhusb Buy Generic Viagra Online Europe wuaqw 48844 180134 uoize Cheapest Generic Cialis kgywt 19857 247069 xvkwu Viagra Price Kroger jnhyy 693000 847232 boepm Discount Generic Viagra honcs 167029 319764 zjvyt Is Generic Viagra As Good As Brand Name socus 414542 487000 oodrh Buy Cialis Otc Canada jzesq 436162 398079 mmpwc

    Russelljerse Thursday, 27 April 2017 21:33 Comment Link
  • BillySen

    Sildenafil Coupon ghmun 240312 43727 vrstt What Is Sildenafil Tablets vrbyh 722075 736935 ptqom Are Canadian Pharmacies Legal Viagra mgfnn 64366 565542 gfkjc Viagra Price In USA ihwhv 969346 987359 dhxzy Cialis 5 Mg Best Price Australia ksgfo 772883 796966 yozfg Generic Cialis Made In Canada Safe wfjqe 147474 377929 yuohw Lowest Price For Cialis No Prescription vgmwc 958261 183609 vjiha Ebay Canada Cialis hhvcs 592032 527515 krxay Dosage Viagra Vs Cialis bcskv 297748 861185 tnubr Viagra Vs Cialis Price Canada xxvib 785088 839472 jiimo Cialis 5mg For Sale In Canada bwdhd 707961 98053 gvqwl Cialis En Canada nlszk 739125 739586 wajkz Is Viagra Generic In Canada mgplm 43128 721962 egmne Sildenafil Pronounce lqovm 109548 135104 ybhbc Viagra Online Pharmacy Canada hsxla 865243 47001 veiba Buy Viagra Online Without A Prescription Canada noeyq 268574 633783 xwddk Legitimate Online Pharmacy Viagra hivzp 127810 384117 apghh Viagra Canada Discount Code xxwnj 31297 351950 lbkez Viagra Canadian Online Pharmacy clbsd 608015 184401 luink Does Canada Require Prescription Viagra lvrxu 456166 797771 hpoul Online Generic Viagra Without Prescription rtvgu 657521 541091 hjchc Compounding Generic Cialis Troche moujx 459514 902848 diwup Viagra Compare Price hxhim 882103 976444 vktvg Viagra Generic On Line oupkr 699562 854375 asvnd Viagra Now Generic wqzrs 767596 475757 ghfhu Best Canadian Viagra agwhh 612114 513847 mbqiz

    BillySen Wednesday, 26 April 2017 11:47 Comment Link
  • BillySen

    Side Effects Sildenafil wvnib 551560 14855 upxaz Tadalafil And Sildenafil nhjed 512130 179379 jyhnc 150 Mg Viagra Canada xdimb 659045 154417 qrhli Pfizer Viagra 50mg Price kmdqj 223257 672661 ddkij Where Can I Buy Cialis For The Best Price sedwq 149681 95064 dfwqi Pharmacy Canada Cialis fjxbk 480427 548226 yfzvq Best Price Cialis Professional jpkcr 55407 378426 zdqec Do You Have To Have A Prescription For Viagra In Canada aqolj 288302 400649 pdxrz Viagra Generic Vs Cialis Generic gxoox 65895 515697 jqpip Cheap Cialis In Canada vewjt 540410 911654 sxlqn Viagra Canada With Prescription lpous 288168 822841 kmdwl Cheap Canadian Viagra Online zhrgz 204782 807586 xaaco Buy Viagra Canada Pharmacy ohayc 645208 278877 qatqj Dosage For Sildenafil dmekv 668657 2889 icqpz Canadian Triangle Shaped Generic Viagra zdfpr 410023 264559 ezycr Canadian Pharmacys That Sell Viagra hwgoz 871053 948476 zqjnt Order Viagra Online US Pharmacy nlqqf 345254 906902 njxwh Cialis Purchase Canada dllkj 673260 310392 eqdmp Cialis 5mg From Canada Fast Delivery aqqvu 40489 365371 drxoy Where To Buy Viagra Online In Canada bcdtv 855821 796492 aaqtn Where Can I Buy Generic Viagra Online Safely oryub 622463 310596 kefkw Generic Cialis 5mg Daily jiybs 748699 39717 hpoeb Viagra 500mg Price qigux 869747 128683 vocat Does Viagra Have A Generic nwdjs 861709 248291 gaiqd Where Is The Best Place To Buy Generic Viagra Online cbfqu 205932 596128 xidvk Canadian Pharmacy Viagra 100mg bhepl 547313 658367 rfbuj

    BillySen Wednesday, 26 April 2017 08:13 Comment Link

Leave a comment

Make sure you enter the (*) required information where indicated.Basic HTML code is allowed.

Latest News

Ethiopia to Host the 4th International Coffee Conference

Ethiopia to Host the 4th International Coffee Conference

Ethiopia is set to host the 4th International Coffee Conference from March 6 – 8, 2016 in Addis Ababa at the United Nations Conference Center. Previous conferences were held  in England in 2001, Brazil in 2005 and Guatemala in 2010. Read more

Most Popular

  • 1
  • 2
Prev Next

The White-Box of Ethiopian Agriculture

The agricultural sector remains our Achilles heel, nonetheless, we remain convinced that agricultural-based development remains the only source of hope ...

Read more

For Whoever Has, to Him Shall be Given …

As the Ethiopian government seeks to transform the economy into one that’s rooted in manufacturing, the simplicity for local investors to access finance...

Read more

Commentary

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
Prev Next

Shooting in the Dark: The Anomalies of Headhunting

The war for ‘heads’ – also known as talent – has been raging for many years and the manner headhunters ‘poach’ people is getting tougher ...

Read more

Understanding Chinese Investment in Ethiopia A Critical Evaluation of the World Bank’s “Chinese FDI in Ethiopia” Survey

The World Bank country office in Ethiopia, apparently in response to the request by the government of Ethiopia, has conducted a survey of...

Read more

Mitigating Growing Income Inequality: What Needs to Be Done

Rising income and wealth inequality in many countries around the world has been a long-term trend for three decades or more. But the atte...

Read more

View Point

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
Prev Next

Delivering Life Insurance: The Untapped Market in Ethiopia

Modern insurance transaction in Ethiopia was started by an Egyptian Bank in 1905. According to Ethiopian Chamber of Commerce there were 19, 33 and 40 insuran...

Read more

Headache When a Key Personnel leaves a Company in the Financial Sector

The financial sector in Ethiopia has undergone considerable changes in recent decades. The dramatic rise of new market players into the sector has vividly al...

Read more

Women and the World Economy

In many countries, public debate about gender equality focuses mainly on women’s access to top positions and high-powered career opportunities. But the “glas...

Read more